Recently, Baidu Maps has caused widespread controversy over the placement of advertisements on the virtual road surface of the navigation interface. These advertisements not only cover lane guidance lines, but can also interfere with the driver’s attention and cause driving safety hazards. This article delves into the business logic behind Baidu Map’s advertising strategy, analyzes its pros and cons in the form of advertising in driving scenarios, and its different commercialization path from Amap.
1. The navigation interface is surprised by the appearance of “road advertising”: when the driving scene encounters commercial intrusion
1. Phenomenon hits: Advertisements “paving” virtual lanes
Recently, a user [once again declared, only one Diudiu, Baidu itself said it was a DEMO test] reported that when using Baidu map navigation, advertising slogans such as “Tired and sleepy and drinking Dongpeng Special Drink” suddenly appeared on the virtual road surface of the 3D view, and in some scenes, the advertisements even covered the lane guidance line, which seriously interfered with information recognition in night mode. Such advertisements do not obviously close the entrance, and are jokingly called “welded to death on the navigation interface” by netizens.
[Picture from Baidu]
2. Public opinion repercussions: the double torture of safety and experience
User doubts focus on two core issues:Driving safety hazardsandUser experience deteriorates。 According to simulation tests by Tsinghua University’s Automotive Safety Laboratory, when an advertisement appears in a curve or ramp, drivers’ reaction time increases by 20% and the probability of an accident increases by 15%. Experiments by the Beijing Transportation Research Institute showed that the driver’s braking response to sudden road conditions was delayed by 0.5 seconds when the advertisement appeared, which is equivalent to extending the braking distance of 60km/h by 8 meters. In addition, 73% of users said they would subconsciously read text when ads appeared, with an average attention diversion time of 1.2 seconds, and vehicles would travel blind for 13 meters at a speed of 40km/h on urban roads.
From a legal point of view, such advertisements may violate Article 44 of the Advertising Law, which stipulates that “shall not hinder social and public order”, and Baidu may be liable for 30%-50% of infringement liability if an accident is caused by advertising. Shanghai Bang Xinyang Law Firm pointed out that advertisements that block key information or force them to stay may violate the Road Traffic Safety Law, and users have the right to request to close advertisements and retain evidence to protect their rights.
[Picture from Baidu]
2. Dismantling the concept of commercial transformation: why choose “navigation pavement” as the advertising carrier?
1. Scenario value: high-precision “dynamic traffic pool”
Baidu Map’s business transformation logic is based on “High-value traffic in driving scenarios” Definition:
User status is highly focused
During the driving process, users rely strongly on navigation information, forming “passive attention”, and the efficiency of advertising reach is higher than that of conventional scenarios. The data shows that users pay attention to core interface advertisements for up to 3 times longer than ordinary scenes in driving scenarios.
B-end product manager’s ability model and learning improvement
The first challenge faced by B-end product managers is how to correctly analyze and diagnose business problems. This is also the most difficult part, product design knowledge is basically not helpful for this part of the work, if you want to do a good job in business analysis and diagnosis, you must have a solid …
View details >
Accurate matching of geographical positioning
Combined with real-time location push of surrounding consumption scenarios (such as gas stations, service area advertisements), real-time association of “people-goods-field” is realized. For example, Dongpeng Special Drink chose to implant “refreshing” advertisements in driving scenarios, directly hitting users’ pain points, and increasing the retention rate of advertising memory by 40%.
Monetization in free mode
As a tool app with 573 million monthly active users, Baidu Maps needs to balance servers, data updates and other costs through advertising. In 2024, its advertising revenue accounted for more than 60%, but the number of user complaints increased by 45% year-on-year, exposing the risk of over-reliance on advertising.
[Picture from Baidu]
2. Technology-driven: from “location services” to “business connectors”
Baidu Maps positions itself as an “offline consumption entrance” and opens up the link of “navigation demand → consumption decision” through advertising placement. The “intelligent driving-level lane navigation” technology was originally used to assist autonomous driving, but it was creatively transformed into an advertising carrier, achieving lane-level precision delivery through large models, and increasing advertising exposure by 40%. This “technology reuse” has brought tens of millions of advertising revenue to Baidu and created a new path for the commercialization of navigation software.
3. Text VS Voice: The trade-off between the pros and cons of advertising in driving scenarios
1. Text display advertising: a double-edged sword between visual impact and information interference
advantage
- Strong visual exposure:Large-font, high-contrast advertising slogans directly occupy the focus of users’ attention, which is suitable for brand reinforcement of cognition. For example, Dongpeng special drink advertisements continue to be exposed in long-distance driving scenes, forming a “fatigue scene” mental penetration.
- Flexible Scenario Adaptation:It can be dynamically triggered in combination with real-time traffic conditions (such as pushing coffee discount ads on congested road sections) to improve relevance.
inferior position
- Prominent security risks:Advertisements obscure key information such as lane lines and turn signs, increasing decision-making delays. Experiments showed that drivers took 30% longer time to identify navigation information that was disturbed by ads.
- Strong user resistance:Forced implantation and cannot be closed, contrary to user expectations of “simple tool product interface”. According to user surveys, 78% of respondents said that “free services tolerate ads, but should not come at the expense of security”.
2. Voice Broadcast Advertising: The challenge of balancing auditory penetration with experience
advantage
- Non-visual interference:Transmit information through voice broadcasts in the navigation gap to avoid distraction and meet driving safety requirements.
- High degree of scene integration:It can be naturally connected with navigation commands (such as “turn right 200 meters ahead→XX restaurant promotion”) to reduce user rejection.
inferior position
- Low information reception efficiency:Speech is easily overlooked, especially in complex road conditions, where the memory of advertisements is only 1/3 of that of text form.
- Hidden dangers of auditory fatigue:High-frequency broadcasts may interfere with navigation command recognition, forming a “wolf is coming” effect. AAA research in the United States shows that repetitive voice ads can lead to a 25% decrease in user sensitivity to key information.
4. Panorama of map application profit model: Baidu vs AutoNavi, two different commercialization paths
1. Baidu Map: Ad-driven “traffic monetization”
Core revenue streams
- Scenario-based advertising matrix:Open-screen advertising, search box advertising, POI annotation advertisements (such as priority display of scenic spots/hotels), and navigation interface placement advertisements will account for more than 60% of advertising revenue in 2024.
- Enterprise-grade data services:Providing high-precision map APIs to car companies and logistics platforms is still an important supplement to the impact of new energy vehicles’ “de-high-precision mapping”.
Shortcomings
Over-reliance on C-side advertising imbalances user experience with commercial benefits. In 2024, the number of user complaints increased by 45% year-on-year, with some users choosing to uninstall due to advertising interference.
2. Amap: Ecological collaborative “service value-added”
Diversified profit model
- Aggregation Service Share:Integrate ride-hailing platforms such as Didi and Cao Cao Travel to extract order commissions, accounting for 35% of the business’s revenue in 2024.
- Local life diversion:Linked with Ele.me and Fliggy, it earns commissions through the closed loop of “search-recommend-trade”, forming a “map is the entrance to life services” ecosystem.
- B-side solution:Provide store location data for Wal-Mart, Starbucks, etc., and optimize commercial layout based on passenger flow heat maps.
advantage
User experience and business conversion are relatively balanced, with 873 million monthly active users ranking first in the industry, and Q3 2024 announced profitability. Its advertising strategy focuses more on gentle monetization, such as voice prompt-related services (such as gas station offers), to avoid forced exposure.
3. International Comparison: Google Maps’ “Data Value Mining”
Google Maps mainly passesAPI serviceandLocal advertisingProfit. Businesses can obtain location data through the Google Maps API and pay for what they use. Local ads accurately push nearby business information, such as prioritizing paying merchants when searching for “restaurant”. In addition, Google Maps uses an “ad credit” system that allows users to choose to watch ads in exchange for advanced features (such as offline maps), balancing user autonomy with corporate revenue.
[Picture from Baidu]
5. Future profit breaking point: when navigation maps are no longer just “tools”
1. “Data deep processing” in the era of Internet of Vehicles
Refined operation of vehicle scenes
Cooperate with car companies to develop “exclusive advertising space for driving scenarios”. For example, the charging pile map is embedded with new energy vehicle brand advertisements to achieve accurate reach through on-board screen/voice interaction. Tencent’s AR navigation has been applied in more than 40 models such as BMW and Changan, combining advertising with real-life navigation to increase conversion rates.
Autonomous driving front layout
Provide “high-precision map + business scenario recommendation” service for autonomous vehicles above level 4 (such as automatically planning routes through cooperative gas stations), and upgrade from “navigation tool” to “travel ecological butler”. Baidu Maps has launched a “pure navigation” pre-installation cooperation with a car company to replace advertising revenue through hardware pre-installation fees.
2. From “Free Tools” to “Value Tiering”
Membership subscription system
Paid packages such as “Ad-Free Pure Edition” and “Real-time Traffic Condition Enhancement Edition” have been launched to meet the ultimate needs of high-frequency driving users for experience. Refer to Citibank’s “in-vehicle banking” model in New York to turn advertising into scenario-based services.
Scenario-based value-added services
For long-distance self-driving users, “scenic spot tickets + navigation routes” are sold as packaged products, and pure advertising is monetized through service premiums. Amap’s “AutoNavi Guide” has entered the field of hotel tourism and catering group buying, driving users to reduce emissions by 1.246 million tons in 2024, achieving a win-win situation between business and social responsibility.
3. “Scene reengineering” of space marketing
AR navigation ads
Overlay virtual billboards in real-world navigation (such as displaying brand logos next to AR arrows at intersections) to reduce visual distractions using technological innovation. Tencent AR Navigation uses eye tracking technology to place ads in non-core field of view, balancing visibility and security.
Dynamic event marketing
Combined with real-time traffic events (such as road closures caused by heavy rain) to push emergency service advertisements (such as discounts at nearby car repair shops) to achieve “pain points are marketing points”. For example, a test section of a test road automatically pushed a coffee delivery ad during congestion and saw a 30% increase in conversion rates.
6. Technology ethics and regulatory reconstruction: an industry consensus that balances business and security
1. Technical optimization: Security prioritization algorithm
Drawing on avionics design standards, it automatically turns off advertisements at speeds of > 60km/h or complex road sections; Referring to the EU’s “Guidelines for In-vehicle Human-Machine Interfaces”, the advertising area is limited to no more than 5% of the interface, and the dwell time is <0.5 seconds. Dynamic advertising algorithms need to be combined with eye tracking, brain wave monitoring and other technologies to achieve “unconscious reception” and avoid interfering with driving.
2. Model innovation: value sharing ecology
Explore the “user attention value” quantitative model, which allows users to watch ads in exchange for value-added services (e.g., free voice packs, real-time traffic conditions). Google Maps’ “advertising points” system and Amap’s “low-carbon travel subsidies” have provided paradigms to learn from.
3. Regulatory Supplementation: Establish industry standards
clarify the boundaries of navigation advertisements, and prohibit the implantation of commercial information in core areas such as lane guidance and intersection prompts; Enterprises are required to disclose advertising data every quarter and be audited by a third-party security assessment agency. our country’s “Measures for the Administration of Internet Advertising” should refine the “one-click closure” standard and force platforms to provide explicit closure entrances.
Conclusion: Finding the “golden balance point” between business and experience
Baidu Maps’ “road advertisement” controversy is essentially a radical test of the commercialization of tool products. For users, tolerating ads is premised on “not affecting core functions”; For enterprises, they need to be wary of “short-term income overdraft long-term trust”. As industry experts say: “The ultimate profit logic of map applications should be to allow users to naturally accept business information in the process of obtaining value, rather than treating users as ‘digital assets’ for rough monetization.” ”
Note: This article cites experimental data from the Automotive Safety Laboratory of Tsinghua University, Beijing Transportation Research Institute and other institutions, as well as the provisions of laws and regulations such as the Advertising Law and the Road Traffic Safety Law. The balance between technological innovation and user experience will always be the core proposition of Internet products.
